Tracking says delivered. The customer says it never arrived. It's one of the hardest support tickets to handle, because you can't see the doorstep and the customer can't prove a negative. Here's a step by step way to deal with it, from the first reply to the decision to reship or refund, and how to protect yourself if it turns into a chargeback.
Why this one is tricky
A "delivered" scan tells you where the carrier says the package went, not where it ended up. Most of these tickets turn out to be a package left somewhere unexpected, taken in by someone else in the household, or delivered to a slightly wrong address. A smaller number are theft from a doorstep, and a few are customers who did receive it. You usually can't tell which at the start, so the goal is a process that's fair to honest customers and still leaves you with a record if it escalates.
Check the facts
First, check the facts. Confirm the shipping address on the order matches what the customer meant. Read the carrier's delivery scan for the time, the location, and any photo or signature.
- Address: Does it match what they intended?
- Scan: Time and location of delivery
- Proof: Photo or signature, if any
Small address problems cause a lot of these: a missing apartment number, an old address saved in the customer's account, or a typo in the street name. If the address on the order is wrong because of a customer error, say so kindly, and explain what you can do.
Ask them to check
Second, ask the customer to look around. Packages are often left with a neighbor, at a side door, or in a mailroom. A delivery scan can also come before the package actually reaches the door, so ask them to give it one more business day.
- Neighbors, side doors, mailroom
- Other people in the household
- Wait one more business day
Here's a reply Harbor Goods Co. uses for order #1042: "Sorry your order hasn't turned up. The carrier marked it delivered yesterday at 2:14 pm. Could you check with neighbors, any side or back doors, and your building's mailroom? Sometimes packages show as delivered a little before they arrive, so if it's still missing tomorrow, reply here and we'll sort it out."
Resolve it
Third, if it's still missing, open a claim or trace with the carrier, and decide what you'll do for the customer: reship, or refund. Set a rule ahead of time, by order value, so the decision is quick and consistent.
| Option | What it means |
|---|---|
| Trace | Open a claim with the carrier |
| Reship | Low value, first time |
| Review | High value, or a repeat claim |
A simple rule might look like this for Harbor Goods Co.: under $50 and the customer's first claim, reship the same day and open a carrier trace in the background. Over $50, or a second claim from the same customer, a person reviews it before anything ships. Carrier claim rules and deadlines vary, so check your carrier's own process and file promptly.
If it turns into a chargeback
Sometimes the customer goes to their bank instead of waiting. The dispute usually arrives with the reason "Product not received". Shopify's guidance for this reason is to submit evidence that the customer received the product before the chargeback was made, such as the date and time you fulfilled the order, the billing information used, and the shipping and tracking information. Shopify says it automatically uploads a PDF of all fulfillment events for you.
- ✅ Keep tracking and delivery scans for every order
- ✅ Save your messages with the customer
- ✅ Note what you offered and when
- ❌ Refunding after a chargeback is already open, which can mean paying twice
For a full walkthrough, see how to win an item not received chargeback, and for how a dispute differs from an early inquiry, see inquiry vs chargeback.
Cutting down on future claims
You can't stop every missing package, but a few habits reduce the number of tickets. Send a delivery notification so customers know to look as soon as the scan happens. For higher-value orders, consider a signature or photo-on-delivery option where your carrier offers one. And keep an eye on repeat claimants: one missing package is bad luck, three in a year is a pattern worth a closer look. For tracking questions that come before delivery, see where is my order emails.
Frequently asked questions
What should I do if tracking says delivered but the customer didn't get it?
Check the shipping address and the carrier's delivery scan, ask the customer to check with neighbors and around the property, and wait one more business day. If it's still missing, open a carrier claim and reship or refund based on your rules.
Do I have to refund if the package was marked delivered?
It's your call, guided by your policy and local law. Many stores reship low-value first-time claims and review higher-value or repeat claims more closely.
What evidence do I need for a "Product not received" chargeback on Shopify?
Shopify suggests the fulfillment date and time, the billing information used, and the shipping and tracking information. It uploads a PDF of fulfillment events automatically.
How long should I wait before reshipping?
One extra business day is a common, reasonable wait, since packages sometimes show as delivered before they arrive.
If you handle this every week
Each of these tickets means pulling up the order, reading the tracking and deciding on a response. Reclaim drafts the reply grounded in the real order, tracking and refund history, proposes an action, and escalates anything outside your refund guardrails to a person, in shadow, assisted or autonomous mode. One note: today it builds its queue from your recent orders, and doesn't connect to a helpdesk or inbox yet. See Reclaim.