Many online card orders on Shopify get a fraud risk level: low, medium, or high. The level is Shopify's estimate of how likely the order is to end in a fraudulent chargeback. This guide explains what each level means, where to find it, what Shopify checks, which orders don't get a rating, and how to act on each one.
Find the risk level
Open an order and look at the Order risk section. Shopify's help center says the full analysis appears there, labeled "Order risk evaluation" or "About this order". Medium and high risk orders also get a warning icon next to the order number in your orders list, so you can spot them before you fulfill.
- Order page: The Order risk section
- Orders list: Warning icon on medium and high risk
- Full detail: The risk evaluation inside that section
Make it a habit to scan the orders list for that icon before every fulfillment run. A risky order caught before it ships costs you nothing. One caught after it ships can cost you the goods, the payment and a chargeback fee.
Three levels, three suggestions
Low risk means Shopify suggests you can fulfill the order. Medium means confirm with the customer before fulfilling. High means consider canceling the order.
| Level | Shopify's suggestion |
|---|---|
| Low | “You can fulfill this order” |
| Medium | “Confirm with the customer before fulfilling” |
| High | “Consider canceling this order” |
Notice the wording. None of the three is an instruction. Shopify gives you a recommendation, and the decision to ship, verify or cancel stays with you.
What it checks
The indicators include address verification, the card security code check, whether the customer's location matches the payment method, unusual device or network activity, and whether more than one card was used.
- AVS: Address verification
- CVV: Card security code
- Location: Matches the payment method?
- Device and network: Any unusual activity?
- Cards: More than one card used?
Each indicator on its own has innocent explanations. A customer who moved recently can fail AVS. A traveler can be far from their billing country. The level reflects how the indicators combine, which is why reading the individual results matters more than the label. AVS and CVV codes explained covers what each result code means.
A quick example
Order #1042 at Harbor Goods Co. comes in at $486.69 and shows medium risk. In the evaluation, the CVV matched, but the address check was only a partial match and the customer's location is in a different country from the card. That fits Shopify's medium risk suggestion exactly: contact the customer first. The store emails them, gets a quick and believable answer, and ships. Had there also been several failed card attempts, the picture would lean toward holding or canceling.
Know the limits
Shopify's help center says fraud indicators are available on the Basic plan or higher, and fraud recommendations need the Grow plan or higher, or a store using Shopify Payments. Some orders don't get a recommendation at all.
- Plan: Recommendations depend on your plan and payment provider
- No rating: Test orders, free orders, orders paid in full with a gift card, Point of Sale orders, B2B orders and subscription renewals
- Shopify Protect: If an order shows Shopify Protect information, Shopify says to review the protection status separately from the fraud indicators
- Medium: Still your call
Medium risk is where most of the money is lost, because it is neither safe to ship blindly nor clear enough to cancel. A short review checklist, like the one in how to review risky orders, keeps those decisions consistent.
When the level is wrong
Ratings are estimates, and real customers sometimes get flagged. Gift orders, customers on a VPN or a work network, and buyers shipping to a new address are common examples. Before you cancel, check the customer's order history and contact them. Shopify order risk false positives covers the usual causes. If the order really does look fraudulent, see when to cancel a high risk order.
If you want certain risk levels handled automatically, Shopify's help center notes that you can use Shopify Flow to create fraud prevention workflows that check orders automatically.
Frequently asked questions
Where do I see the fraud risk level on a Shopify order?
Open the order and look at the Order risk section. Medium and high risk orders also show a warning icon next to the order number in the orders list.
Why doesn't my order have a risk level?
Some orders don't receive a fraud recommendation, such as test orders, free orders, orders paid in full with a gift card, Point of Sale orders, B2B orders and subscription renewals. Recommendations also depend on your plan and on whether you use Shopify Payments.
Does Shopify cancel high risk orders automatically?
No. Shopify suggests that you consider canceling a high risk order, but the decision is yours.
Can a low risk order still be fraud?
Yes. The rating is an estimate based on a set of indicators, so a low rating lowers the odds but doesn't rule out fraud.
Going beyond the label
The risk label tells you how worried to be, not what actually triggered it or what to do next. RiskClarity reviews each paid order, explains the risk in plain English with the fraud signals behind it, and recommends allow, verify, or hold, with every decision logged as evidence for chargeback disputes. See RiskClarity.